How The Alt-Right Manipulates the Data to 'Prove' the Existence of Race - 2016-08-09

From UmbraXenu
Jump to: navigation, search
F0.png How The Alt-Right Manipulates the Data to 'Prove' the Existence of Race August 9, 2016, Ari Feldman, Forward

A group of blogs and Internet forums, led by blogger Steve Sailer, have come together to embrace a successor to the pseudoscientific racist movements of the 20th century. "Human biodiversity" (HBD) is the term they have used to give their particular theories a policy-wonk zing. (Read an in-depth explanation of the human biodiversity phenomenon here.) One of the hallmarks of HBD blogs is the use of data and charts from genetics studies to "prove" their theories. This evidence is culled from articles in the leading journals of population genetics and behavioral genetics, and published by some of genetics' leading lights. But what does this evidence look like? And, if they're using cutting-edge research to make their points, does that mean their theories hold some water?

We'll start with the "evidence" itself. Most often it takes the form of what's called a principal component analysis. A PCA is able to boil down a data set comprising hundreds or even thousands of dimensions (think the largest spreadsheet you've ever seen) into a 2D plot. (Or, depending on the type of analysis you're running, 3D, or 4D, and so on.) If you do a PCA of a bunch of distinct genomes from around the world, you'll get something that looks like this:

This PCA chart is from an article called "The population genetics of the Jewish people," by Dr. Harry Ostrer and Dr. Karl Skorecki. Each individual dot represents one genome — one person's DNA. The chart is just one of several data analysis methods they use for showing the genetic "location" of Jews — somewhere between Middle Eastern and European, as it turns out. The chart also shows, quite clearly, that all three of those populations are rather far away from the cluster of sub-Saharan African genomes.

Wikipedia cite:
{{cite news | first = Ari | last = Feldman | title = How The Alt-Right Manipulates the Data to 'Prove' the Existence of Race | url = https://forward.com/news/national/347207/how-the-alt-right-manipulates-the-data-to-prove-the-existence-of-race/ | work = Forward | date = August 9, 2016 | accessdate = December 14, 2019 }}