Roberts Upholds COVID-19 Restrictions on Churches, Scolds Kavanaugh - 2020-05-30

From UmbraXenu
Jump to: navigation, search
F0.png Roberts Upholds COVID-19 Restrictions on Churches, Scolds Kavanaugh May 30, 2020, Mark Joseph Stern, Slate Magazine

Friday at midnight, the Supreme Court rejected a church's challenge to California's COVID-19 restrictions by a 5–4 vote, with Chief Justice John Roberts joining the liberals. In a pointed opinion, Roberts indicated that he will not join conservative judges' escalating efforts to override public health measures in the name of religious freedom. Justice Brett Kavanaugh's dissent, by contrast, falsely accused the state of religious discrimination in an extremely misleading opinion that omits the most important facts of the case. Roberts went out of his way to scold Kavanaugh's dishonest vilification of the state.

SCOTUS' late-night order in South Bay United Pentecostal Church v. Newsom divided the justices into two camps: those who acknowledge reality, and those who ignore it to score ideological points. The case began when a California church accused Gov. Gavin Newsom of violating its religious freedom. Newsom's current COVID-19 policy limits attendance at houses of worship to 25 percent of building capacity or a maximum of 100 attendees, whichever is lower. At the same time, it allows certain secular businesses, like grocery stores, to operate under looser guidelines, allowing more people to enter. The church claimed this disparate treatment between churches and commercial establishments runs afoul of the First Amendment.

As Roberts noted, however, California does not impose uniform rules on all places where people assemble. The state does strictly limit church attendance. But it applies "similar or more severe restrictions" to "lectures, concerts, movie showings, spectator sports, and theatrical performances." So the question for the court is less constitutional than scientific: From an epidemiological perspective, are churches more like grocery stores or concerts? And that, the chief justice concluded, is a question for lawmakers, not federal judges.

Wikipedia cite:
{{cite news | first = Mark Joseph | last = Stern | title = Roberts Upholds COVID-19 Restrictions on Churches, Scolds Kavanaugh | url = https://slate.com/news-and-politics/2020/05/supreme-court-coronavirus-california-churches.html | work = Slate Magazine | date = May 30, 2020 | accessdate = June 1, 2020 }}