The pursuit of herd immunity is a folly – so who's funding this bad science? - 2020-10-18

From UmbraXenu
Jump to: navigation, search
F345.png The pursuit of herd immunity is a folly – so who's funding this bad science? October 18, 2020, Trish Greenhalgh, The Guardian

Earlier this month, in a wood-panelled room at a country estate in Massachusetts, three defiantly unmasked professors gathered around a large oak table to sign a declaration about the global response to the pandemic. One academic had flown across the Atlantic from Oxford; another had travelled from California. The signing ceremony had been carefully orchestrated for media attention, with a slick website and video produced to accompany the event, and an ostentatious champagne toast to follow.

You may not have heard of the "Great Barrington declaration" but you'll likely have seen the headlines that followed it. Journalists have written excitedly about an emerging rift in the scientific community as the consensus around the most effective response to Covid supposedly disintegrates. The declaration, which called for an immediate resumption of "life as normal" for everyone but the "vulnerable", fuelled these notions by casting doubt on the utility of lockdown restrictions. "We know that all populations will eventually reach herd immunity", it stated.

Scientists were swift in their response. The declaration's core assumption, that population immunity will be achieved by allowing life to go on as normal and shielding only the most vulnerable from the virus, is entirely speculative. The thrust of its argument is based on a false opposition between those who argue for lockdown and those who are against it, when in fact lockdowns are one of numerous measures that scientists have called for, and are seen as a short-term last resort to regain control.

Wikipedia cite:
{{cite news | first = Trish | last = Greenhalgh | author2 = Martin McKee; Michelle Kelly-Irving | title = The pursuit of herd immunity is a folly – so who's funding this bad science? | url = https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2020/oct/18/covid-herd-immunity-funding-bad-science-anti-lockdown | work = The Guardian | date = October 18, 2020 | accessdate = October 19, 2020 }}